Follow Christiane on social media:

On Twitter + Facebook + Instagram Amanpour producers on Twitter

What time is Amanpour on CNN?

Check showtimes to see when Amanpour is on CNN where you are. Or watch online.

Check showtimes to see when Amanpour is on CNN where you are. Or watch online.

For Germans: War and conscience

April 27th, 2010
05:45 PM ET

By Frederik Pleitgen; Berlin Correspondent for CNN

Public appearances by top German officials at mourning ceremonies for slain soldiers have become a sad new phenomenon in the country. Last weekend both Chancellor Angela Merkel and Defense Minister Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg were on hand as the military and public bid farewell to four men killed in battle in Northern Afghanistan a little over a week ago. In his eulogy Guttenberg said, “it is in these times that we must ask you, the relatives of those who were killed, for forgiveness.”

It is the second time this month that Merkel and Guttenberg have had to attend such a ceremony. On April 2nd three German soldiers were killed in small arms fire in Kunduz province, then on April 15th four more died when their vehicle was attacked in Baghlan province during a patrol. The attacks came at a time when public support for Germany’s mission in Afghanistan are at an all time low, with up 70 per cent calling for a fast withdrawal from the country.

Researchers like Jan Techau from Germany’s Council on Foreign Relations believe politicians have long tried to avoid a debate on the use of military force in the country and now those lapses are catching up with them.

“The fact that we have a military but don't really like it, the fact that we send soldiers abroad to do horrible things but don't really appreciate it. This is a psychological predisposition of this country."

Techau and many others believe that psychological predisposition stems from Germany’s past, starting World War II, the crimes committed during the holocaust, and finally the total defeat. It has led Germans to become staunch pacifists, Techau says, who like their military but have never been prepared for the reverberations of the army’s actions in war zones.

Thus many of the German soldiers who are serving in Afghanistan feel a distinct lack of support from their population.

"The lack of support really worried me in the beginning, but now I have decided I want to go to Afghanistan, I don't need anyone's support, I don't care what other people say." That is what Norman, a German soldiers about to deploy to Afghanistan, whose full name we cannot print because of the army’s security policy told me shortly before deploying to Kunduz, the most dangerous area in Northern Afghanistan where Germany is leading NATO’s efforts. In the face of waning public support, Germany only pledged some 500 additional soldiers, as well as a reserve of some 350, late last year when the U.S. asked countries participating to increase their troops levels in support of ISAF commander Gen. Stanley McChrystal’s new partnering strategy, which saw America commit some 30 thousand additional soldiers.

Germany’s Defense Minister zu Guttenberg told CNN he knows he needs to do a better job of selling the mission to the public.

"We are trying to explain to our population what they are doing there, why they are doing it and what the key elements in Afghanistan are. It's quite important to be frank and clear and blunt."

According to Jan Techau from the Council on Foreign relations, German politicians need to start being more honest with their population now, otherwise the debate on German military power will come to them as casualties mount. Defense Minister Guttenberg made a start at the ceremony for the killed soldiers last weekend.

“In this day and wage we need to understand that more Germans will be killed abroad in Afghanistan and elsewhere,” he said speaking in a church in Ingolstadt in Bavaria.

The week before German Chancellor Merkel held a speech in parliament where she acknowledged the lapses of the best but also made a commitment not to leave Afghanistan unilaterally.

“The international community went into Afghanistan together and we will leave together. We won’t stay longer than necessary but we also won’t stay any shorter.”

German politicians have said the new strategy in Afghanistan which sees NATO soldiers partnering with Afghan units to conduct military operations and will see the expansion of foot patrols rather than riding in safer mine proof vehicle will mean more German soldiers will be harmed. At the same time the country is now realizing that for years it hasn’t adequately supplied its forces in Afghanistan with the gear they need to survive. In all of Afghanistan the German military has only eight transport helicopters and no gun ships. Meaning the troops have to rely on the U.S. army in case they get involved in heavy fighting.

This was the case on April 2nd when German soldiers were pinned down by insurgents in Kunduz and several wounded were medevaced out of the area by American helicopters as the Germans did not have adequate capacities of their own.

Last week the German Defense Minister presented Gen. McChrystal with medals of honor for the U.S. soldiers who risked their lives to save the Germans. Guttenberg acknowledged the Germans need to upgrade their soldiers’ capabilities. A difficult task at a time when most Germans want to see their soldiers leave the country as soon as possibly.

Filed under:  Germany
soundoff (7 Responses)
  1. Rufus

    Welcome back to the world Germany. Its ugly. Empire is a horrible waste of lives and treasure, but multilateralism mean YOU have to get involved. Its not just about the US defending Germany...its about the West defending some form of civilized government in Afghanistan...

    April 27, 2010 at 7:32 pm | Reply
  2. Nana Abdul

    I would just like to notify the world,that people instigates i was shocked to see the numbers of calls for the brithish leaders to apologize to the pope,but one idiot who did the cartoon of the prophet,the most sacred servant of Allah,who is most regarded,not the priests that are all covered with sins of child molestation for years.nobody had called for the stupid danish to apologize.

    April 28, 2010 at 1:39 am | Reply
  3. Leonardo

    If only the reason for being there was honestly given to the people, then their soldiers would get the support they should get for their mission, but most people believe its all about OIL. If this is true, then let the OIL Companies get mercenaries to do their dirty work.

    There is also the question of DRUGS. The American backed War Lords are sending TONS of drugs into EUROPE & America turns a blind eye.

    I also believe the American Government delibertly forces young men to join the Army by removing factories out of their cities & making them unemployed. The only alternative left is join the Army.

    CNN & others should be exposing these OIL parasites for what they are & young people should know the real reason why they are in places like Afghanistan.

    April 28, 2010 at 10:09 pm | Reply
  4. Moira

    The psycological disposition of the past that will lie embedded forever. If they continue down this path They know it, and they know the world know's it too. The use of military force as the only politician's economic policy tool. The people had to put up with that for a long time. Now, this generation have the right to a new identity, not under some old forgies( politicians who can't be frank with people who put them their in the first place).

    April 29, 2010 at 4:33 am | Reply
  5. Becket

    I believe that from their experiences, the Germans understand that warmongering is not the beginning and end, unlike their US and British counterparts. The Germans were called everything in the book and now the US having seen a change of character in the Germans (war was in the blood of Germans) want them to behave like murderers again. Unlike the Brits, the German population does not want to be Vassals of the US. The war on Iraq was based on lies; the ongoing war in Afghanistan is now based on lies as there is no Al Qaida there. The USA has been the most militaristic State in the last 2 centuries. The German politicians, who kowtow to the US, will do so at their peril.

    April 29, 2010 at 12:07 pm | Reply
  6. Free American

    WOW! The Germans have 500 soldiers in Afghanistan!!!
    How many TENS of THOUSANDS of American soldiers are still in Germany? How many US Bases are still in Europe? WWII ended in 1945.
    We have FIFTY Thousands US Military personnels in a small Japanese Island called OKINAWA. Can the average American find it on the map? Check ATLAS! P L E A S E!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Once you find OKINAWA; imagine NINETY THOUSANDS Japanese Demonstrators who demonstrated against the US Military Base in OKINAWA and the Japanese want it removed. I wanted it relocated to Arizona.
    Do you know how many US Military Bases are around the World?
    I doubt our Reps in Congress NOR the Senate know???? NOT even John McCain of Arizona knows who has been an Arizona Senator for DECADES and his BORDERS are like a SIEVE!!!!!
    It is about time to RELOCATE our WORLDWIDE Military Bases to our OWN BORDERS with Mexico & Canada!
    Let's start with US Bases in Germany and Japan.
    In addition; Who needs Fort Bragg (or Fort Bennings or others) in the Middle of the USA? Relocate them all Forts to Arizona!

    April 29, 2010 at 4:05 pm | Reply
  7. Kindra

    This web site really has all the information I wanted concerning this subject and didn't know who to ask.

    Here is my web site :: JGrW

    December 3, 2020 at 7:23 pm | Reply

Post a comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.